Cut down your winners and hold the losers or vice-versa?

An equity market is an amusing place. Different people react differently to losses and gains.

There could be two different perspectives on the same investment.

Let’s take an example of a mutual fund – Scheme A. Let’s consider two investors with not much experience & skills in investing – Raju and Gopal bought Scheme A on the same day and for the same amount.

Scheme A has incurred a loss of 20% when all other schemes are positive. Raju and Gopal think differently about Scheme A:

– Raju thinks since the scheme is performing poorly when all others are doing good, let’s sell it off and reallocate the investments to good-performing funds
– Gopal feels that a 20% correction gives an opportunity to buy more in Scheme A since it is now cheaper than the first buying price

Who do you think is correct in their assessment?

Either could be correct with the outcome of the actions they will take but both are wrong regarding the reason for taking that action.

One should never buy or sell an investment based on the initial purchase price. The buying or selling should entirely be based on

1. Whether the current price is less or more than the intrinsic/fair value of the investment
2. The weight of the investment in the overall portfolio, and
3. The conviction with the investment

You will always be aware of the price of an investment but that is of no help unless you know how to evaluate intrinsic/fair value and astutely design a portfolio allocation. Portfolio management requires skills that can be brought by a seasoned investor, professional investment advisor, or analyst.

Another important point is to evaluate investment in the context of the entire portfolio. Each investment has a role to play in the portfolio which could be diversification, tactical allocation, negative correlation, etc. and that should not be forgotten while managing a portfolio.

In a bull market, every rock looks shiny but only in a bear market do we discover real diamonds.

Originally posted on LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/sumitduseja

 
Truemind Capital

Share
Published by
Truemind Capital

Recent Posts

Who will take over your investment decisions after you?

Have you ever thought about who will take care of your family investments after you?…

1 week ago

Do you really know the risk in your portfolio?

I am getting 16% returns on my portfolio.One of my friends said that. What is wrong…

3 weeks ago

How to do sanity check of your investment portfolio?

What could be wrong in a portfolio managed by well-known wealth management companies? I met…

4 weeks ago

Financial market round-up – Oct’25

At Truemind Capital, our broad understanding has been: Equity markets will underperform owing to pricey…

2 months ago

The reasons we work for :)

6 months ago, I met a lady who came to me through a reference to discuss…

2 months ago

Should you still invest in Gold at current prices?

Gold has rallied 50% in the last year and at a CAGR of 29% in…

3 months ago